Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: PS3 VS XBOX 360 ..which one better?
Lancerzone Forums - Lancer Grand Touring Club Malaysia > Other Interest > IT & Gadgets
Pages: 1, 2, 3
ZeN
work has been h*ll last 6 months. 2 reorgs, cost cutting etc. etc.

hopefully the next 6 months is much better...
my ps3 needs my attention too...
Economist
How come most ps3 games are on 720p while x box games are on 1080p? any reason?
SC999
thot already discussed before??
Economist
QUOTE(SC999 @ Jun 23 2009, 09:44 AM) *
thot already discussed before??


got mer? i thought we discuss y some games look diff on ps3 n xbox...coz of the diff reso...but i dont understand y ps3 games still running on 780p while xbox games seems more advanced in terms of reso
SC999
aiya, its like that one la.

M$ got money mah. no la, just kidding.

mainly due to XB more mature alrady , i guess
terion
actually all if not most games comes in 720p.. only PS3 exclusive games seems to come in 1080p native.

the reason xbox games all in 1080p is because xbox has a hardware upscaler that upscales all 720p games to 1080p so thats why it seems to look better on generic games (games that are release for all platforms ps3/xbox/wii/pc)
Economist
QUOTE(terion @ Jun 23 2009, 11:32 AM) *
actually all if not most games comes in 720p.. only PS3 exclusive games seems to come in 1080p native.

the reason xbox games all in 1080p is because xbox has a hardware upscaler that upscales all 720p games to 1080p so thats why it seems to look better on generic games (games that are release for all platforms ps3/xbox/wii/pc)


ohhhh no wonder.......
SC999
i dont think its a upscaler. it it is upscaler then its interpolated, not pixel anymore.
wans81
maybe off topic but anybody know how to separate XBOX graphics audio...means i want hdmi cable as picture but for audio want to use my mini hifi AUX...
Economist
QUOTE(wans81 @ Jun 23 2009, 11:48 AM) *
maybe off topic but anybody know how to separate XBOX graphics audio...means i want hdmi cable as picture but for audio want to use my mini hifi AUX...


terion, we did this at nick's place on the ps3..how ah?
SC999
u need to buy a separater, that allow u to use HDMI port to go to TV, then optical to Hi-Fi
wans81
QUOTE(SC999 @ Jun 23 2009, 11:50 AM) *
u need to buy a separater, that allow u to use HDMI port to go to TV, then optical to Hi-Fi


Thanks bro....i will get this thing? how much aa it will cost?
terion
econs, on ps3 it comes with separate composite cable, so we used the sound from there but the video from HDMI.

sean, definitely got an upscaler inside xbox

QUOTE
On the Xbox 360, the games that aren't rendered natively at 1080p are upscaled using a built in upscaler, while on the PS3 the developers must ensure upscaling support.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1080p#Video_game_consoles
SC999
upscaler definitely in there, what i meant was the graphic on 1080P or 1080i on XBOX360...upscaler not only available in Xbox 360, PS3, at the era of PS2 already inbuilt. so that the 'gigi' 3D graphic on PS1 game when play via PS2 will look smoother.
QUOTE(wans81 @ Jun 23 2009, 12:02 PM) *
Thanks bro....i will get this thing? how much aa it will cost?
it will only cost u couple of ten bucks only.
terion
sean, very easy only... when playing ur xbox game... just chk the TV setting la... it will tell u mah whether its running on 1080p or 1080i... but i think it upscales to 1080p... if 1080i then no point also...lol
SC999
yap, when i not sure, i will then press the 'DISPLAY' button.

coz u know la, ahem game mah, sometime the cover information alsways not accurate one. haha!
Economist
eh 1080i and p both HD....still dont udnerstand wats diff btw interlaced and progressive.......
SC999
later to expalin la, go google la!

aiyo!

live experiece. from bare eye to compare 720P VS 1080i, 720P won.
terion
difference between 1080i and 1080p

QUOTE
The progressive-scan versions of the 1080-line resolution is known as 1080p. Current digital television broadcast systems and standards are not equipped for 1080p50/60 transmission. Also, the majority of consumer televisions offered for sale are currently not equipped to receive or decode a 1080p signal at any frequency. It is less bandwidth-intensive to broadcast a movie at 1080p24 than 1080i60, since 20% less data would be transferred. In addition, when the source material is 24 frames per second, as are most films, it would be easy to convert a 1080p24 broadcast to an NTSC 1080i60 format using a 3:2 pulldown process (see telecine). Moreover, displaying a p24 broadcast on an i50 system (such as PAL) requires the speed of video and audio be increased by over 4% (to 25 frames per second).

Therefore a hybrid is often used for movies and the like: the frames (25 or 30 per second) are segmented into two interlaced fields with equal time index (psf, progressive in or with segmented frames). The deinterlacer has to perform a simple weave only. This ensures compatibility with 1080i50/60 with only little less coding efficiency than 1080p25/30 and half the bandwidth requirement of 1080p50/60, but the SDTV problems of PAL speed-up and Telecine judder remain.

It is less efficient to transmit any signal with a frame rate significantly higher than that of its source, which is 24fps for movies, however frame differencing in the compression standards used for HDTV transmission greatly reduce the wasted bandwidth in these cases.


.

basically u only get 1080i these days from HDTV broadcast or from recordings from older video cams which do not support the 1080p format yet.

see the screenshot below for an example of a 1080i quality video



see here for more info: http://satellitetvguru.net/1080i-vs-1080p/
aLFiaNz
QUOTE(wans81 @ Jun 2 2009, 11:46 AM) *
1. Xbox360 not advise to play for long hours, may hang ..any comment?

2. In terms of graphics, which one? heard PS3 have more experience and high technology..

3. For long term, which one can stand longer in the market?



1. are u sure???? i always play my xbox 360 every day from 8p.m till 1a.m..ok jer....

2. i still choose xbox 360....

3. xbox 360....
Economist
QUOTE(aLFiaNz @ Jun 24 2009, 11:38 AM) *
1. are u sure???? i always play my xbox 360 every day from 8p.m till 1a.m..ok jer....

2. i still choose xbox 360....

3. xbox 360....


xbox i think depends on luck...really many case of 3ROD....
Reverend
Right when the XB360 and PS3 were launched, I had spoken to quite a few game developers (I was really into 3D graphics then). Here are some of my email exchanges with THE GOD John Carmack (Doom, Quake) :

QUOTE(John Carmack)
QUOTE(Reverend)
I do have one question. You'd told me before about your preference for the XB360 over the PS3. For any given targetted framerate (say, a locked 30fps), which of the two consoles would give better graphics? Would the difference be significant?


The difference would not be significant, they are quire comparable in raw power.

John Carmack



QUOTE(John Carmack)
QUOTE(Reverend)
I know you guys haven't made any announcements about your upcoming game but being a PS2 owner and will be upgrading to the PS3 (and ignoring the XB360), can you tell me (that can or cannot be posted; please tell me) the differences we'll see on these 3 consoles? Naturally, given my area of interest, I'm more interested in the graphics aspects but any stuff outside of graphics are also very much appreciated.


The graphics are going to be very similar on XB360 / PC / PS3. At launch time, the PC will have more powerful graphics cards available (at a premium price) than either console. The PS3 will be the biggest hassle to develop on, and the extra theoretical CPU power of the cells isn't going to translate into improved games.

John Carmack


Also, just for everyone's info... about the cost of making video games :

QUOTE(John Carmack)
QUOTE(Reverend)
I know this has been a worrying trend for some time now but I'm wondering what your thoughts are on some games costing as much as, if not more than, a movie. I mean, it's ridiculous to me that a game (even one targeting ALL platforms) to cost between $50-100 Million! There was a time when I followed closely these developments and I still fail to see how a game can cost so much. I'm not even sure any more about my understanding of game development.
What part(s) of game development can suck up anywhere more than $10 Million, much less $50 or $100 Million?!?


Salary. Many games use over 100 people now, and fully burdened costs are near $100k each (higher at id, rather lower in other places). Burning $10M a year is easy. Burning four years on a game is not that hard. Add in other costs, and you can hit $50M. I don't think the game that hits $100M is in production yet, but it will certainly happen within a decade.

Id isn't going to spend $50M on a game soon, but others in the market will.

John Carmack


That was 3 years ago :) Making video games now is a very expensive thing.

Hope this is informative :)
terion
if ur played the latest red alert, u know y its becoming so expensive... its more like a movie with all those famous actress and actors in it... sure la will reach almost 100 mil...
Economist
do they still sell new 6axis ps3 controller? saw some1 selling new at rm130....
axenophage
can PS3 play ciplak DVD movie??
terion
boleh but not recommended....

if ori DVD ok, it can upscale to 1080p lagi...
Economist
QUOTE(terion @ Aug 12 2009, 09:16 PM) *
boleh but not recommended....

if ori DVD ok, it can upscale to 1080p lagi...


still not sure the reason for this..since the lense doesnt touch the disc......
SC999
the density of pirated DVD is not as rich as ori one.

thus giving unnecessary stress for the lens
Economist
QUOTE(SC999 @ Aug 13 2009, 09:32 AM) *
the density of pirated DVD is not as rich as ori one.

thus giving unnecessary stress for the lens


IC.......i will tell this to ppl who alwiz ask me y!......hahah thanks........
Reverend
I think I have just encountered the dreaded "lens failure" problem on my PS3, altho' I'm not sure.

PS3 games aren't being recognized after loading. This happened after a NFS Prostreet game hanged while playing. So I ejected the game disc and tried to re-start. Can restart but hanged while during intro.

Tried other games, same thing... either game disc not being read (after loading the disc) or if the game does start, it will hang.

However, BluRay movies seem to work fine... :/

Will prolly send in to MidValley Sony SC tomorrow.
Economist
QUOTE(Reverend @ Aug 31 2009, 06:22 PM) *
I think I have just encountered the dreaded "lens failure" problem on my PS3, altho' I'm not sure.

PS3 games aren't being recognized after loading. This happened after a NFS Prostreet game hanged while playing. So I ejected the game disc and tried to re-start. Can restart but hanged while during intro.

Tried other games, same thing... either game disc not being read (after loading the disc) or if the game does start, it will hang.

However, BluRay movies seem to work fine... :/

Will prolly send in to MidValley Sony SC tomorrow.


Do they service non msia set?????....hope everything is ok........this is diff fr the yellow light prob?
Reverend
QUOTE(Economist @ Sep 1 2009, 09:00 AM) *
Do they service non msia set?????....hope everything is ok........this is diff fr the yellow light prob?

I don't know if they will service non local sets but will enquire. Yeah, this is not the YLOD problem coz there's no yellow light :/
Economist
yellow light also lense prob?..........if not haf to find fr LYN some reputable ppl to fix it...........worse case ps3 slim....1250...or thereabouts =)
terion
this lens problem is normal... most shops i think can service it by just changing the lens, few hundred ringgit i think

but i doubt Sony SC will entertain non-malaysian set

the YLOD is a diff and bigger prob, that one if kena, u can't even start ur machine...
Economist
bugger few hundred............sienzzzzzzzzzzzzz.......my machine als few hundered only hahah
terion
see here for more info on how to change the lens: http://forum.lowyat.net/topic/494788


ActionKamen
Xbox 360 is what you need
Reverend
Confirmed Sony Malaysia will not entertain parallel import sets. Took it to the shop where I bought my unit and they said they know about the problem coz they just repaired one unit blink.gif They will change the lens and it will cost me about RM4xx, d*mn!
Economist
QUOTE(Reverend @ Sep 1 2009, 12:16 PM) *
Confirmed Sony Malaysia will not entertain parallel import sets. Took it to the shop where I bought my unit and they said they know about the problem coz they just repaired one unit :blink: They will change the lens and it will cost me about RM4xx, d*mn!


half the price of my set!!!!!!!!
Reverend
QUOTE(Economist @ Sep 1 2009, 12:25 PM) *
half the price of my set!!!!!!!!

Yeah... but what to do? Must repair lo...

Anyway, I think I know how the lens in my PS3 failed. My son was playing InitialD and wouldn't let me quit the game/shut down the PS3 because he wanted to continue the game whenever he wanted to. So the PS3 was switched on for about like 5-7 days non-stop, while the InitialD game was paused. I think the lens kaput because it was constantly reading the InitialD game disc for 5-7 days.
terion
wah lau... leave the game in pause for few days???? doh.gif

u should read this FAQ here: http://forum.lowyat.net/topic/1118828

QUOTE
There have been several cases of lens problems with PS3. While there is no solid explanation for these lens failures (one theory is the overheating of the lens), I'll just list down some of the best practices recommended by our community here.

- if possible, remove the BD from PS3 before you shut it off (advice from Bernard of GS)
- in any case of freeze/lockups, eject any disc in the drive first before attempting to restart the system. This will lower the risk of the BD drive problem - vorchiel
- a few have theorized the questionable quality of pirated DVD movies may overly-stressed the BD laser leading to failures, best avoid them
- as always, don't place the ps3 in a closed off cabinet with restricted airflow. make sure the placement of the ps3 don't block any of its vents.
- Try not to place your PS3 on the same level that you place your front speakers. The sounds generated from the speakers regardless low or high volume will cause some low or high vibration across the AV cabinet or table panel and this might have a negative damage impact on the BD mechanism lens and it parts (especially when the lens is in reading mode, the sensitivity is much greater to any shock or vibration) - raoul
Reverend
QUOTE(terion @ Sep 1 2009, 12:42 PM) *
wah lau... leave the game in pause for few days???? doh.gif

Yeah... but It's A Sony... it should work even in such a scenario, hahaha :P :) :)
Economist
QUOTE(Reverend @ Sep 1 2009, 12:38 PM) *
Yeah... but what to do? Must repair lo...

Anyway, I think I know how the lens in my PS3 failed. My son was playing InitialD and wouldn't let me quit the game/shut down the PS3 because he wanted to continue the game whenever he wanted to. So the PS3 was switched on for about like 5-7 days non-stop, while the InitialD game was paused. I think the lens kaput because it was constantly reading the InitialD game disc for 5-7 days.


BUGGER U MAD AH????????????? y in the world did u do dat???????????
Reverend
QUOTE(Economist @ Sep 1 2009, 01:15 PM) *
BUGGER U MAD AH????????????? y in the world did u do dat???????????

Not mad... just that :

1. I didn't know cannot leave PS3 running for a few days while a game is running
2. I love my son :)
Economist
QUOTE(Reverend @ Sep 1 2009, 02:00 PM) *
Not mad... just that :

1. I didn't know cannot leave PS3 running for a few days while a game is running
2. I love my son smile.gif


DIDNT KNOW? wui common sense

anyway there's a line btw loving n spoiling...but who am i to judge ya.........
Reverend
QUOTE(Economist @ Sep 1 2009, 02:06 PM) *
DIDNT KNOW? wui common sense

anyway there's a line btw loving n spoiling...but who am i to judge ya.........

Well, maybe I lacked that little bit of common sense lo... my son says "Don't switch off... " and I have a lotta stuff to do...

You calling me stupid ah, Econ? :P

Trust me... if there's a line between "loving" and "spoiling" your kid, you will not recognize it... until you are told the difference between the two.

I'll see what happens when Econ. Jr is around ;) :)
terion
back to topic

PS3 firmware 3.00 is out... get it here: http://asia.playstation.com/sg/en/support/osDetail/71830
Economist
this time i will be smart.........use flash drive!!!!!!!
terion
yupe its faster too.. tried updating the office one and it was taking ages... download via PC soooooo much faster...
Economist
but dont update also ok one right?...phobia!
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.